Shiv vs Holliday
Shiv's team wins 46.4% Holliday's team wins 53.6%, across 29,980 games
Written for the Shiv player. Playing Holliday? See Holliday vs Shiv →
Shiv has the edge
Shiv usually wins 44.8% of games. Against Holliday that is 1.6% higher, over 29,980 games.
- Whole match 46.4% +1.6% vs usual 29,980 games
- Sharing a lane 46.8% +2.0% vs usual 8,281 games
- Oracle and above 45.9% −1.2% vs usual 1,603 games
"Sharing a lane" counts only games where both were assigned the same lane — the laning matchup itself. "Oracle and above" counts only matches whose average rank was Oracle and above, against Shiv's usual win rate at that rank.
The fight at a glance
If you're Shiv
Has the edgeWait out Bounce Pad 41s cooldown
ThenForce her to place it defensively, then commit while it is on cooldown.
- Watch out
- Powder Keg Knockup into a
Crackshot
Crackshot Her headshots deal bonus damage and apply a fading movement speed penalty. Crowd Control a fading movement speed penalty; Damage about 55 bonus damage at base; Defensive the slow is a kiting tool against a chasing bruiser 1 about -20% additional fading move speed penalty 2 about +49.5 damage and -6% Bullet Resist on the target for 5 seconds 5 about -6s cooldown on hero headshots and -3s on NPC headshots headshot is her kill combo. - Your edge
- Shiv has more healing than Holliday, so you recover between fights and they do not.
- Buy
Slowing Hex
Slowing Hex +29s Cooldown +3.5s Duration +0.1s Cast Delay +16% Move Speed -26% Dash Distance Buy it against Holliday's
Spirit Lasso
Spirit Lasso Throws a lasso that deals spirit damage, pulls the target toward her, and stuns them. Crowd Control pull (displacement) plus stun (hard CC) Damage about 80 spirit at base (deadlock.one) Mobility she can relocate while lassoing, dragging the victim with her 1 +80 damage 2 -40s cooldown .
If you're Holliday
Wait out Slice and Dice 16s cooldown
WhyIt is his engage and his disengage on one 16s cooldown; a Shiv who dashes at a trooper wave or a durable frontliner has no way to reach or leave your backline for the next 10-16 seconds.
- Watch out
- Killing Blow executes you outright below 18% (23% with 2 ability points) from 12-18m away.
- Your edge
- Holliday has more crowd control than Shiv.
- Buy
Divine Barrier
Divine Barrier +55s Cooldown +0.2s Cast Delay +1.5 Out of Combat Regen +6s Buff Duration +600 Barrier +10% Ability Range +10% Radius Buy it against the backline assassination from Shiv.
The full plan for Shiv, phase by phase, is below. Holliday's side in full →
What should I do right now?
Do
- Plan for
Slowing Hex
Slowing Hex +29s Cooldown +3.5s Duration +0.1s Cast Delay +16% Move Speed -26% Dash Distance — know which tier it sits in so you are not improvising at the shop. - Know what
Bounce Pad looks like. It is the cooldown this lane revolves around.
Avoid
- Walking to lane on the same path every wave against a hero with Holliday's engage range.
Do
- 10-round magazine at roughly 2.1 shots per second means whiffed shots are very expensive
- No self-heal or sustain of any kind — chip damage accumulates on her with nothing to offset it
Serrated Knives
Serrated Knives Shiv throws a knife that damages and bleeds the target. Crowd Control Applies a movement slow with the bleed; Damage 32 impact damage plus 10 bleed DPS per knife stack over a 5s debuff; 1 1 AP: +2s debuff duration 2 2 AP: +2 charges (four knives available for a full stack dump) 5 5 AP: +7 bleed DPS per stack, and +0.01 spirit scaling on the full-Rage impact damage give him free chip at range with 2 charges on a 16s cooldown, which wins the health-bar war without him ever entering shotgun range
Avoid
Powder Keg clears the wave quickly and pokes the enemy laner in the same cast
Crackshot ignores falloff, so she can harass from ranges where her opponent cannot answer
Do
- Their first real spike is ult unlock — respect it from that point, not before.
- Your spike is ult unlock:
Killing Blow makes every low-health enemy within 12m a guaranteed kill and turns on the Rage passive that upgrades all three basic abilities
Avoid
- Taking an even fight against Holliday on their spike timing when you could take the same fight ten minutes later on yours.
Do
- Watch for
Spirit Lasso.
Unstoppable
Unstoppable +60s Cooldown +5.5s Duration +125 Bonus Health +25% Debuff Resist Builds from Debuff Reducer pre-cast makes you immune to the Stun and the pull outright — hold it for her ult if she is on the enemy team - Hold
Unstoppable for
Spirit Lasso — it is a targeted Stun-and-pull and
Unstoppable simply negates it
Avoid
- Spending your own escape before
Bounce Pad is on cooldown.
Holliday’s abilities
-
Spirit Lasso Ultimate The one cooldown worth tracking on its own timer: pull (displacement) plus Stun (Hard CC).
Unstoppable pre-cast makes you immune to the Stun and the pull outright — hold it for her ult if she is on the enemy team- It is a single-target targeted throw — keep a wall or corner between you and her sightline when her ult is up
Ethereal Shift
Ethereal Shift +37s Cooldown +4s Duration +5s Buff Duration +30% Spirit Resist +20 Spirit Power makes you untargetable through the pull window
-
Powder Keg Ability 1 Holliday gets on top of you and then keeps you there — Knockup on detonation, Hard CC that removes the target's ability to strafe.
- Shoot the barrel to detonate it early on your own terms, before you are in the blast radius
- The delay is generous — simply walk out of the marked area rather than trading through it
- If you get knocked up, do not panic-dash on landing; she is waiting for the predictable landing spot for her
Crackshot headshot
-
Bounce Pad Ability 2 Nothing to respect until the upgrade lands, and then tier 3 adds about +0.7s Stun to the landing stomp.
- The pad is a visible placed object with a long lifetime — route around it rather than through it
Knockdown
Knockdown +35s Cooldown +0.1s Cast Delay +2s Stun Delay +0.5s Stun Duration +75 Bonus Health +5% Ability Range +5% Radius hits her out of the launch arc; she is fully committed and cannot change direction mid-flight- The stomp only triggers once per person per pad, so absorbing it with a durable body neutralizes the AoE for the rest of the fight
-
Crackshot Ability 3 This will not kill you on its own — it makes sure you cannot leave while the rest of Holliday's kit does. A fading movement speed penalty.
- Strafe unpredictably and keep your head behind cover — a Crackshot that misses the head is just a 19.7 damage pistol shot
- It is on a cooldown, so after eating one headshot the next several seconds are her weakest window — push in then
- Fight her in close quarters where she cannot line up a head; her fire rate of about 2.1 per second punishes her badly in a brawl
- 1
Bounce Pad Bounce Pad first — it is her escape, her rotation and (at tier 3) her engage. Force her to place it defensively, then commit while it is on cooldown
- 2
Powder Keg Powder Keg second: make her spend it on the wave or on a durable frontliner, because without the Knockup her
Crackshot combo is just a slow pistol shot - 3
Spirit Lasso Spirit Lasso is best baited by a target holding
Unstoppable or
Ethereal Shift — the ult goes on full cooldown for zero value
The matchup in detail
- Zero sustain and low durability — she cannot absorb a committed dive Strong evidence
- Damage is entirely aim-gated; a Holliday who is not hitting heads contributes very little Strong evidence
- Every one of her tools is telegraphed — a visible barrel, a visible pad, a targeted lasso Strong evidence
-
Powder Keg Knockup into a
Crackshot headshot is her kill combo — while airborne you cannot strafe and the headshot is effectively guaranteed Strong evidence -
Spirit Lasso pulls you out of your team and stuns you, and with a
Bounce Pad she drags you even further before the Stun ends Strong evidence -
Crackshot ignores damage falloff, so distance does not actually protect you from her burst the way it does against other gun heroes Strong evidence -
Bounce Pad tier 3 delivers her whole team onto your backline from above with a landing Stun on arrival Strong evidence - Stacked overlapping barrels in a tight interior create a burn zone that punishes holding a chokepoint at all Strong evidence
- Hold
Unstoppable for
Spirit Lasso — it is a targeted Stun-and-pull and
Unstoppable simply negates it Strong evidence - Shoot
Powder Keg barrels to detonate them early, before you are inside the blast, and deny the Knockup that sets up
Crackshot Strong evidence - Buy
Knockdown for her
Bounce Pad launch arcs and for her keg self-launches — she is fully committed in the air with no direction control Strong evidence - Brawl her inside 10m: her roughly 2.1 shots per second and 10-round magazine lose badly to any SMG hero in close quarters Strong evidence
- Break her sightline immediately after she lands a
Crackshot headshot — the bonus is on cooldown and she is a weak pistol hero for those seconds Strong evidence - Stay grouped so that a lasso pull delivers you into your allies rather than into hers Strong evidence
- Against Holliday the item that changes the matchup is
Slowing Hex, and not for the slow. It silences movement abilities and movement items — that is their dash, their blink, their
Warp Stone
Warp Stone +16s Cooldown +30% Bullet Resist +6s Buff Duration and their
Phantom Strike
Phantom Strike +35s Cooldown +0.35s Cast Delay +8 Spirit Power +15% Weapon Damage +40% Move Speed +3s Slow Duration all turned off at once — and raises their gravity to 120% on top. At Tier II Spirit for 1,600 it is the cheapest way to convert a mobility advantage into a stationary target, and you deal the Spirit Damage needed to apply the follow-up. Strong evidence - Holliday starts the fight and you have no exit, so the defensive active you buy has to work when you did not see it coming.
Unstoppable is the stronger effect — immunity to and a dispel of Stun, Silence, Sleep, Root and Disarm for 5.5 seconds — but it must be pre-cast, and it cannot be activated once you are already stunned, which is precisely the situation this hero creates.
Indomitable
Indomitable +55s Cooldown +10s Duration +10% Bullet Resist +10% Spirit Resist +20s Cooldown On Apply +2 Out of Combat Regen Builds from Reactive Barrier auto-cleanses the next Hard CC with no input from you; against an initiator that reliability beats the bigger number. Strong evidence
- The few seconds after any
Crackshot headshot lands, while the bonus is on its own cooldown Strong evidence - Her reload — 2.75 seconds with only 10 rounds is a long, frequent dead window Strong evidence
- Mid-air on
Bounce Pad or a keg self-launch: she has no directional control and
Knockdown ends the flight Strong evidence - Immediately after
Spirit Lasso resolves — the pulled target is now standing next to a low-durability hero with her ult spent Strong evidence - Any close-quarters brawl she is forced into Strong evidence
- Holliday's pull is the whole matchup. Until it is on cooldown you are playing around it; once it misses you have a window that is worth committing into. Make it the first thing you bait — show a sliver of yourself from behind cover rather than walking a clean line they can lead. Strategic
- Being stunned by Holliday now pauses your reload rather than restarting it, as of 09-16-2026. That quietly changes when it is safe to reload in this matchup: a reload caught by their Stun resumes where it left off instead of costing you the whole cycle, so the old rule of never reloading inside their engagement range is too conservative now. The compensating change is that parrying also pauses your reload, so a defensive parry no longer buys you free reload time. Documented
- Around 6:00 the Guardians become realistically contestable and players start leaving lane for Haunt camps Haunts Lanes and Districts across the map Haunts replace the old neutral camps. They are not a reskin: each type behaves differently, and the health bar now shows a camp's soul value and how hard it is, so you can decide whether a camp is worth your time before you start shooting. Three eye colours mark the tier — teal for tier I, yellow for tier II, red for tier III. Souls 4168181 souls tier I / II / III a creep +0.44 / +0.73 / +1.95 a minute — which for you means the map stops being a 1v1 and Holliday gains the thing they are best at, the opening engagement onto a target with no way out. The last two minutes before that transition are your safest window to build a soul lead. After it, treat any position without a teammate in line of sight as a position they can start a fight in. Strategic
- You get value from moving around the map and Holliday does not, but the 09-16-2026 patch made that harder to convert early: tunnel breakables Crates Streets, rooftops and tunnels — about 500 of them Ordinary breakables. Each has a 60% chance to drop souls; a Tough Crate always drops, for double. Souls 23 souls a crate, 60% of the time +2 a minute now spawn and respawn on 5 minutes rather than 3. The off-lane income that used to make a rotation pay for itself is roughly 40% less frequent, so before 6:00 a rotation has to be justified by pressure on Holliday or on the Guardian, not by the breakables you pick up on the way. Documented
-
Powder Keg clears the wave quickly and pokes the enemy laner in the same cast Strong evidence -
Crackshot ignores falloff, so she can harass from ranges where her opponent cannot answer Strong evidence - 10-round magazine at roughly 2.1 shots per second means whiffed shots are very expensive Strong evidence
- No self-heal or sustain of any kind — chip damage accumulates on her with nothing to offset it Strong evidence
-
Serrated Knives give him free chip at range with 2 charges on a 16s cooldown, which wins the health-bar war without him ever entering shotgun range Strong evidence
- There is a hard behavioural change at 20:00 in this matchup: respawn goes from 35 to 38 seconds as of 09-16-2026, and you are the hero Holliday can pick off without a fight starting. Three seconds does not sound like much until you price it against the Rift's 7-minute cadence and the Urn at 20 and 25 — a single death now reliably costs you presence at the next objective. Past 20:00, stop taking the solo camp that is one rotation from their side of the map. Documented
-
Spirit Lasso unlock — Gives her a guaranteed pick and the ability to remove one enemy from a fight entirely Strong evidence -
Bounce Pad tier 3 — The roughly +0.7s landing Stun turns her mobility tool into a genuine engage Strong evidence -
Crackshot tier 2 — About +49.5 damage plus a bullet-resist shred makes each headshot a real burst window Strong evidence - Mid 20-35min — Keg-launch plus
Bounce Pad plus lasso is the window where her kidnap plays dictate objective fights Strong evidence
-
Killing Blow unlock — Makes every low-health enemy within 12m a guaranteed kill and turns on the Rage passive that upgrades all three basic abilities Strong evidence - 1 AP into
Slice and Dice — -6s cooldown (16s to 10s) lets him engage and still hold an exit dash in the same fight Strong evidence
- Against Holliday's knockups,
Debuff Reducer
Debuff Reducer +25% Debuff Resist +90 Bonus Health is a live answer where it used to be a dead one: Knockup durations were brought under debuff reduction on 05-22-2026, so the +25% from a 1,600 Tier II item genuinely shortens the airborne time. That matters more for you than for most, because you have no exit and the airborne window is when their follow-up lands. Worth pairing with the fact that
Knockdown-style effects going the other way still cannot be shortened at all. Documented - Holliday brings enough lockdown that Stun sequencing matters. Community reporting describes Stun diminishing returns of roughly 10% then 30% inside an 8-second window, applying to stuns only and not to silences, slows, disarms or hexes — so their follow-up chain may be shorter than the first one felt. Treat this as unconfirmed, but it is worth knowing before you burn a cleanse on the opening Stun. Uncertain
- Holliday decides where you stand, not you. The practical rule is to never hold a position whose failure case is being moved — stand so that being yanked or knocked puts you somewhere survivable rather than inside their whole team. Cover at your back is worth more than cover in front. Strong evidence
- Fight Holliday under cover — indoors, under walkways, inside stairwells. Taking away the vertical axis removes most of their kit's value before you spend a single item slot on it. Strategic
- Holliday fights from the air, which is exactly what
Knockdown exists for: it applies +100% gravity to an airborne target (raised from +50% in March 2026) and its Stun scales with altitude, up to about +1.5s at 30m. The higher they commit, the harder the punish — and Debuff Resist will not shorten that Stun for them. Documented - Against Holliday's crowd control, understand what Debuff Resist actually buys you: it shortens duration, never magnitude. It is excellent against long disables and close to worthless against a short hard slow. Two things it explicitly does not shorten at all are the parry Stun and the
Knockdown item's Stun. Documented -
Slowing Hex (spirit T2) — Holliday's
Spirit Lasso is what you are buying against here. Buy it when an enemy repeatedly uses a movement ability or item to dash, blink or fly out of your kill window. Documented -
Knockdown (spirit T3) — Buy whenever an enemy fights from the sky — it answers flying and airborne heroes and channelled aerial ultimates. What you are answering here: Holliday's
Bounce Pad. Documented -
Phantom Strike (vitality T4) — Buy to catch flying or long-range heroes who otherwise never enter your range, and to Disarm a gun carry mid-burst. What you are answering here: Holliday's
Bounce Pad. Documented
- The instinct here is to buy
Dispel Magic
Dispel Magic +45s Cooldown +10% Spirit Resist +3s Buff Duration +250 Heal Amount as your answer to Holliday and then find it greyed out at the exact moment you need it.
Dispel Magic cannot be cast while you are stunned or asleep, and it cannot remove a Stun at all — it purges what comes with the Stun, not the Stun itself. Against Holliday the item you actually want is the pre-cast kind (
Unstoppable, which also cannot be activated once you are already stunned) or the automatic kind (
Indomitable, which cleanses the next Hard CC with no input from you). Documented - The losing pattern against Holliday is deciding to leave, walking to the zipline and finding you cannot attach. Any damage from an enemy hero or objective blocks zipline attachment for 3 seconds, and Holliday has the chip range to keep that 3-second timer rolling indefinitely. Break line of sight first, wait out the lockout, then attach — do not walk to the rope while still taking fire. Documented
- Players buy
Dispel Magic for Holliday and then discover it does nothing about
Spirit Lasso.
Dispel Magic purges non-ultimate negative effects only — anything sourced from an ultimate is outside its scope entirely. Work out which of Holliday's disables come off abilities and which come off the ult before you spend 3,200: the ability-sourced ones are purgeable, the ult is not, and for the ult you need either
Unstoppable pre-cast or the discipline not to be there. Documented - Your instinct is to jump on Holliday's backline the moment you see an opening, and the mistake is not checking what is above you. A Walker's Stomp is 350 damage + 15% of your max health inside 15m with a 2-second Stun on a 7-second cooldown — a 2-second Stun handed to a team with peel is a death. Dive under their Walker only with
Unstoppable pre-cast or after the Stomp has just gone off. Strong evidence
Next
Shiv’s other hard matchups
All of Holliday
Who beats Holliday, the items that shut Holliday down, and every ability.
Facing more than Holliday?
Add the other five enemies: who to focus first and what to buy against the whole team.
Sources and method for this page
Everything on this page is generated for Deadlock patch 10-30-2026 from Holliday's current kit, measured match results and a mechanics rule base. Each line carries its own confidence label.
Data-supported Measured: you win 46.4% of these, which is 1.6% above your overall win rate (29,980 matches). The kit-based model reads this as moderate instead — treat the measured number as primary and the gap as a sign this matchup is more about execution than kit.
Holliday's kit and counterplay were compiled from 5 sources, cross-checked for patch 10-30-2026. Threat ratings compare this pairing against Shiv's own baseline win rate rather than a flat 50%, because ranking by raw win rate produces the wrong answer for heroes whose overall win rate is not 50%.